Bright Data and Oxylabs are the two largest proxy and scraping vendors, and most shortlists contain both. Their price pages do not line up, though. Each sells several products, each meters some by request and some by gigabyte, and both run promotions. This post puts the two on one scale, dollars per 1,000 pages, and then totals a monthly bill.
Rates come from our two single vendor posts, Bright Data pricing per 1,000 pages and Oxylabs pricing per 1,000 pages. Both vendors change plans often, so check the live pages from brightdata.com and oxylabs.io before you commit a budget. The totals below are our arithmetic, rate times volume, and ignore tax, proxy add ons and any negotiated discount.
Two different meters
Both vendors have a fetch and parse product billed per request and a proxy or unblocker product billed per gigabyte. Bright Data calls the first Web Unlocker and the second residential proxies. Oxylabs calls them Web Scraper API and Web Unblocker or residential proxies. Compare like with like: a per request product with a per request product, a per GB product with a per GB product. Mixing them is how a 1.50 USD headline turns into a 6 USD bill.
Per request rates for ordinary rendered pages
| Plan | Bright Data Web Unlocker | Oxylabs Web Scraper API, other sites with JS |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | 1.50 USD pay as you go, free tier of 5,000 requests | 1.50 USD on Starter at 30 USD, 5 USD welcome credit |
| Around 100 USD | 1.50 USD, no plan needed | 1.40 USD on Basic at 100 USD |
| Around 500 USD | 1.30 USD on the 499 USD tier, 383,000 requests | 1.30 USD on Flexible at 500 USD, 384,000 results |
| Top public tier | Enterprise, negotiated | 1.22 USD on Enterprise from 2,500 USD |
| Amazon pages | 1.50 USD on Unlocker, prebuilt Scraper APIs from 0.75 per 1,000 records | 0.50 USD on Starter, 0.25 on Enterprise |
At the 500 USD level the two are almost identical, 383,000 against 384,000 included requests. The difference is in what each rate covers. Oxylabs prints a separate rate per target type, so a Google results page and an ordinary rendered page are priced apart. Bright Data uses one Unlocker rate for any site, which is simpler to forecast.
Per GB rates when you run your own crawler
| Product | Bright Data | Oxylabs |
|---|---|---|
| Residential proxies, entry | 8 USD per GB list, 4 USD with the current coupon | 6 USD per GB |
| Residential proxies, largest published plan | 2.51 USD per GB on 1,999 USD for 798 GB | 2.50 USD per GB |
| Unblocker per GB | Not sold per GB | 7.20 USD at entry, 3.00 USD on Enterprise |
A 1.5 MB rendered page is about 1.47 GB per 1,000 pages. At 4 USD per GB that is 5.86 USD per 1,000, at 2.50 it is 3.68. Per GB billing only beats the per request products when your pages are light, around 150 KB of HTML, where 1,000 pages cost 0.37 to 1.17 USD. If you have not tuned the crawler to block images and fonts, per GB is the expensive meter on either vendor.
Monthly bill at 100,000, 500,000 and 1,000,000 pages
Assume every page is an ordinary site that needs rendering, and compare per request products at their listed rates. Bright Data uses pay as you go at 1.50, then the 499 USD tier with 1.30 on overage. Oxylabs uses the rendered rate of its plan. WebScrap uses the smallest plan that covers the volume. These are our numbers from the rates above, not quotes from either vendor.
| Pages a month | Bright Data Unlocker | Oxylabs Web Scraper API | WebScrap |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100,000 | 150 USD | 140 USD at the Basic rate | 149 USD, Growth |
| 500,000 | About 651 USD (499 plus 117,000 at 1.30) | 650 USD at the Flexible rate | 499 USD, Scale |
| 1,000,000 | About 1,301 USD (499 plus 617,000 at 1.30) | 1,300 USD at the Flexible rate | 499 USD, Scale |
At 100,000 pages the three are within 10 USD, so pick on integration and support. The gap opens above roughly 380,000 pages, because the 499 USD Scale plan includes 1,500,000 requests while the two vendors keep charging about 1.30 per 1,000 for every request past their included amount. A page behind a bot wall costs the same on our plan as a plain article, and blocked requests are not billed. Our Bright Data alternative and Oxylabs alternative pages show the same comparison per vendor, and pricing lists every plan.
Where each one wins
Bright Data wins on a free tier of 5,000 Unlocker requests for testing, 800 plus prebuilt Scraper APIs from 0.75 USD per 1,000 records, ready made datasets and a very large IP pool with fine geo targeting. Oxylabs wins on Amazon at 0.25 to 0.50 USD per 1,000, published per target rates, a 5 USD welcome credit and enterprise support. If most of your volume is Amazon product pages, choose Oxylabs and ignore the rest of this post.
A flat plan wins when the workload is mixed, protected and large, because the monthly bill is a request count times one rate. Teams comparing three or more vendors can add the Zyte rate card and the Decodo rate card to the same spreadsheet. For per GB billing details, see residential vs datacenter proxies.
Questions buyers ask
Is Bright Data cheaper than Oxylabs? For rendered pages on ordinary sites the per request rates are close. Bright Data Web Unlocker is 1.50 USD per 1,000 pay as you go and 1.30 on the 499 USD tier. Oxylabs Web Scraper API is 1.50 per 1,000 rendered results on Starter and 1.30 on Flexible. Oxylabs is cheaper on Amazon, Bright Data on its free tier.
How much does Oxylabs cost per 1,000 pages? Oxylabs Web Scraper API lists 1.00 USD per 1,000 results for ordinary sites and 1.50 with JavaScript rendering on Starter, falling to 1.22 on Enterprise. Amazon is 0.25 to 0.50. Web Unblocker is billed per gigabyte instead, from 7.20 USD per GB at entry down to 3.00.
Which has cheaper residential proxies, Bright Data or Oxylabs? Bright Data lists residential proxies at 8 USD per GB, 4 with a current coupon, and 2.51 USD effective on the 1,999 USD plan. Oxylabs lists them from 6 USD per GB down to 2.50 at the top tier. At the same volume tier the two are within a dollar of each other.